The Wie bloom is officially off the rose

Interesting how time changes the media’s opinion. Take Michelle [photopress:wie.jpg,full,alignright]Wie, for example. At the start of her first year as a professional, with William Morris Agency backing her and a big Nike deal in her pocket, the world appeared to be her oyster.

Apparently that oyster was a little bit rancid. Over the past couple of days, as Wie plays the same tournament in which she was disqualified from last year, she has been hammered by the press. In my mind, this story has become a question of lost potential, and apparently that’s how the NY Times is seeing it as well.

The paper took the opportunity, in an article written by Damon Hack entitled “Wie swings and misses,” to the embarrass Wie over her failure to live up to the self-endorsed hype:

In her professional debut a year ago at Bighorn Golf Club, she dodged bumblebees and bunkers before being disqualified for signing an incorrect scorecard. On Thursday, at the same course, she raised an iron above her head, brought it down toward the ball and connected with the dirt instead.

“Completely whiffed it,” she said, giggling. “It was a really bad situation.”

But Hack doesn’t stop there. He has great quotes on Wie’s lack of progress from lots of sources, including David Leadbetter, who seems to be questioning Wie’s hectic schedule which has seen her flounder in the fall.

“Playing the John Deere was badly planned,” David Leadbetter, Wie’s swing coach, said in an interview Tuesday. “It was after the U.S. Open and the match play, and then she goes out there and she’s exhausted, and the whole thing was just not well organized. These are things you learn as you as go on.”

Even without the heatstroke, Wie was not playing well at the John Deere Classic, where she opened with a 77. The theme continued throughout the summer; in September, she shot scores of 78 and 79 at the European Masters and 77 and 81 at the 84 Lumber Classic.

Wie’s father, BJ, isn’t talking on the subject of his daughter. He ignored requests from the Times for an interview. This is surprising as he’s always had time to shoot his mouth off about the remarkable abilities of his daughter. There must be a lot of pressure on him as well, given how regularly he’s been second guessed for taking Wie professional so soon, and without a regular spot on the LPGA Tour. As for Wie, she continues to make remarks that remind me, after all, she has just turned 17.

“I think it’s so sweet that everybody has so many concerns for me,” said Wie, a senior at the Punahou School in Honolulu.

However, as an Associated Press article points out, maybe the public is growing tired of the teen sensation who has been less than sensational:

Wie is simply trying to win for the first time, and despite looking like a lost cause, she hasn’t lost hope.

“I was in some bad situations,” Wie said. “My game is feeling really good. It’s really close right now.”

The gallery was about one-fourth the size as last year, and the only buzz was coming from the bees hovering around desert fauna.

Related Articles

About author View all posts Author website

Robert Thompson

A bestselling author and award-winning columnist, Robert Thompson has been writing about business and sports, and particularly golf, for almost two decades. His reporting and commentary on golf has appeared in Golf Magazine, the Globe and Mail, T&L Golf and many other media outlets. Currently Robert is a columnist with Global Golf Post, golf analyst for Global News and Shaw Communications, and Senior Writer to ScoreGolf. The Going for the Green blog was launched in 2004.

2 CommentsLeave a comment

  • RT:

    As you know, Wie did place in the top five in three of four woman’s majors this year. Yes, her continuing struggle with the men’s tour is obvious but overall progress in her game is being made….contrary to the tone and impression left by you and other golf writers.

    Her father is a head case and she has lots of pressure but I applaud her for taking on a big challenge. Breaking new ground as she is doing has plenty of naysayers. Being truely innovative and unique takes guts, drive, focus, and determination. This is one blog poster that hopes she has those elements and can do it.

  • Though I was a huge Wie supporter at the beginning of the year, I’m now of the opinion that she’s a sideshow circus act. Playing the men’s tournaments was a bad mistake from the beginning, and now she’s lost all her confidence to boot. She needs a real management team.


Leave a Reply